The Klog Mutar
Monday, January 17th, 2011“Don’t call between nine and ten,” my mother intones on our answering machine. “I’m watching Larry King. He’s got that ghastly story about: [kidnapping] [school bus accident] or [celebrity cancer victim.]”
My grandma Lena, who spoke only Yiddish, had a word for people like this. She called them Klog Mutars, which roughly translates to ‘Disaster Mother.’ Klog Mutars trade calamitous tales like sick currency, thriving on the high drama brought on by other people’s bad decisions, desperate behavior or run-of-the-mill misfortune.
I want to tell my mom that our son lost a tooth and that he is student of the week. But I am preempted.
“Did you hear about Pat McAllister’s husband? It’s just so depressing.”
“I don’t know Pat McAllister, mom.”
“Well the husband has pancreatic cancer!” she says emphatically. Score another one for the Klog Mutar.
“Are you watching Larry King?” she asks.
“I hate Larry King,” I reply.
“Well you might want to turn him on,” she continues.
For my mother, Larry King is the ultimate in bad news delivery. The little man in suspenders seems to have an in with the grim reaper himself.
Why are we so titillated by other people’s tragedies? Do they help us to ignore our own vulnerability? Is there relief in knowing the plane we will take next week is now statistically less likely to crash into a mountainside? I despise the Klog Mutar because she makes me aware of all that we can’t predict, control or fix.
If I can’t do anything to help — cook a meal, wipe a brow, solve the crime and jail the killer, why do I need to know about the misery at hand?
“Please don’t tell me about the plane crash Mom,” I implore.
“Well you can’t run away from the real world!” she replies heatedly.
I think of my father, the doctor, so different from the Klog Mutar. He soothes the husband grieving for his wife. He comforts the parents of the 16-year-old who has driven off a cliff. He puts the neighbors’ kids to bed and cleans up the kitchen when she is too inebriated to get off the couch.
He speaks of his patients with compassion and admires their ability to carry on, despite the wreckage of their lives. He gets no joy from the gruesome accidents and heartbreak he witnesses every day.
“How do you bear all of the sadness?” I frequently ask him.
“You get down on your knees with gratitude,” he replies, “for all that goes right.”
I know that I can’t stop a jet from hurtling out of the sky. I understand that doctors can’t detect every lurking disease and that I will not be able to track my teenage child at any given hour of the night.
But I am not powerless before the Klog Mutar. I look her squarely in the eyes and count my blessings.
8 Comments
subscribe comments feed- A Clock Ticks As A Mom Tries Not to Be Pissed (24)
- Life Lessons from Dog to Child (18)
- Ditch the Care Bears and Have Some Ice Cream (16)
- Marin Mommies (14)
- From California to Congo: A Mom on a Mission (14)
- When Will People See? (13)
- Mad for Mad Men (13)
- The News No Parent Wants to Hear (13)
- Trust Your 'Mom' Instincts (12)
- Togetherness Is Nothing Like Being Alone (11)

Fantastic Aly! Oh so true! My mom is one of those too so I can so relate. Glad I got my dads gene and always look for the good. Yasher koach! Keep em coming! Marci
This disaster-seeking feels so familiar in my Own Jewish world. I love your perspective and strategy!
I like your dad’s approach. Maybe there’s not much we can do to prevent life from happening the does, but there is much we can do, helping others through service.
Ultimately we can choose to be fueled by our actions (compassion, gratitude) rather than be passive bystanders to tragedy.
thanks for the lovely succinct juxtaposition of both sides.
Tell your mom to call me. I also have a morbid need to rehash drama that is NOT in my control. If only to be grateful that things could always be much worse.
Great piece!
I love this piece- I have the same reaction about not wanting to hear about things unless I can positively impact them. This isn’t a strategy everyone employs, so I was glad to hear you put it into words.
Hey you wonderful writer, it’s your friend, Ingrid. I was looking for you on facebook, while Jonah said, doesn’t she prefer real letters?… and then I ended up on linked-in and found my way here…and i am so touched that you mention our letters, and i owe you one. We must keep the US Postal Service in business! so, ing
it is hard to carry the weight of the world when we are trying to balance the present we are given
I love it! “I want to tell my mom that our son has lost a tooth and that he is student of the week. But I am preempted.”
I could swear I was hearing my mom in Chinese — even though it’s your grandma in Yiddish!